Application of Liquid Carbon Dioxide in the Selective Extraction of Rare Elements

This post is also available in: Persian Armenian

In recent decades, rare and strategic elements have become one of the fundamental pillars of advanced technological development worldwide. The rapid growth of industries such as advanced electronics, renewable energy, electric vehicles, aerospace, medical equipment, and digital technologies has generated increasing demand for specific elements whose extraction and processing are not always simple or cost-effective using conventional methods. These elements—commonly referred to as rare elements or strategically valuable elements—play a critical role in enhancing performance, improving efficiency, and enabling the miniaturization of industrial and consumer equipment.

Alongside rising demand, the limited availability of high-grade mineral resources and environmental concerns associated with traditional extraction methods have directed researchers and industry toward alternative and more sustainable technologies. Classical hydrometallurgical and pyrometallurgical methods, although well established industrially, are typically associated with high acid consumption, the generation of contaminated effluents, and significant treatment costs. Under such conditions, the use of advanced fluids such as liquid and supercritical carbon dioxide has emerged as a technological and environmentally friendly option.

Due to its unique physical and chemical properties, liquid carbon dioxide can function as a tunable solvent. This characteristic has led to extensive research in recent years on the use of liquid CO₂ for the selective extraction of valuable compounds, including rare elements.

Rare Elements: Industrial Position and Importance

Rare elements refer to a group of chemical elements that, despite their name, are not necessarily geologically scarce. However, due to their wide dispersion in the Earth’s crust, low concentrations in ores, and the complexity of separation processes, their extraction and economic utilization present significant challenges. These elements are typically dispersed within various mineral structures and are rarely found in high-grade deposits comparable to metals such as iron or copper. As a result, their processing requires multiple chemical and physical stages.

Among these, rare earth elements (REEs), comprising 17 elements of the periodic table, hold a particularly important position. Owing to their unique magnetic, optical, and electrochemical properties, they play a critical role in advanced technologies. Permanent magnets used in wind turbines, electric vehicle motors, and advanced electronic devices are practically impossible without elements such as neodymium and dysprosium. Rare elements are also widely used in optical displays, lasers, optical fibers, industrial catalysts, and high-strength specialty alloys.

The importance of rare elements extends beyond industry into strategic and geopolitical dimensions. The concentration of major mineral reserves and processing capacities in a limited number of countries has created global supply chain dependencies. In recent years—particularly with the expansion of clean energy and digital industries—governments and major corporations have increasingly focused on securing stable supplies of rare elements. As a result, many countries are investing in innovative extraction technologies, recycling, and the utilization of secondary resources such as industrial waste, electronic scrap, and spent batteries.

Within this framework, the selective extraction of rare elements from secondary sources is not only a technical solution but also an economic and environmental strategy. This approach reduces dependence on primary mining while simultaneously contributing to waste management and pollution reduction.

Challenges of Conventional Extraction Methods

Traditional extraction methods for rare elements are primarily based on hydrometallurgical and wet chemical processes. In these approaches, minerals or waste materials are first subjected to dissolution using strong acids, followed by separation processes such as ion exchange, solvent extraction, and selective precipitation. Although technically established and widely applied, these methods involve numerous limitations.

One of the most significant challenges is the high consumption of corrosive and toxic chemicals, which increases operational costs and creates substantial safety and environmental risks. The management of acidic effluents and chemical residues requires advanced treatment systems and considerable additional expenses. Furthermore, selectivity is often insufficient, leading to the simultaneous extraction of chemically similar elements and complicating downstream purification.

Another major issue is high energy consumption, particularly in pyrometallurgical and thermal operations. This not only increases production costs but also elevates the carbon footprint of the process. As global industries move toward reducing greenhouse gas emissions, this factor has become a serious constraint.

These combined challenges have encouraged the mining and processing industries to seek alternatives that maintain or enhance extraction efficiency while minimizing chemical consumption, waste generation, and environmental impact.

Liquid and Supercritical Carbon Dioxide

Carbon dioxide is one of the simplest yet most widely used industrial chemical compounds. Under standard conditions, it exists as a gas. By increasing pressure and controlling temperature, CO₂ can be converted into a liquid state and, under specific conditions, into a supercritical phase. Its critical point occurs at approximately 31°C and 74 bar—relatively mild conditions compared to many other supercritical fluids.

In the supercritical state, CO₂ exhibits properties intermediate between a gas and a liquid. Its high density provides solvent capability, while its low viscosity and high diffusivity enable rapid penetration into porous solid structures. This unique combination makes supercritical CO₂ an attractive solvent for extraction processes.

Another key advantage is that CO₂ is non-toxic and non-flammable. After completion of the process, it can be easily removed from the system by pressure reduction and subsequently recycled. These characteristics make CO₂-based processes safer, more environmentally compatible, and economically attractive compared to many organic solvent-based systems.

Principles of Selective Extraction with Liquid CO₂

The extraction of rare elements using liquid or supercritical CO₂ combines the fluid’s physical properties with targeted chemical reactions. Since most metallic elements in ionic or mineral form are not directly soluble in CO₂, auxiliary agents play a critical role. These typically include complexing agents or co-solvents capable of chemically binding to the target element and rendering it soluble in the CO₂ phase.

In a typical process, the feed material—such as mineral concentrate, industrial ash, or electronic waste—is placed in a pressurized reactor. Liquid or supercritical CO₂ is injected into the system and brought into direct contact with the solid matrix. The complex formed between the chemical agent and the target element selectively transfers into the CO₂ phase, while unwanted components remain in the solid residue.

After extraction, pressure reduction or temperature adjustment causes CO₂ to revert from its liquid or supercritical state, allowing recovery of the concentrated extracted element. This step is highly efficient in terms of time and energy because it eliminates the need for organic solvent evaporation or chemical neutralization.

Practical and Industrial Applications

The use of liquid CO₂ in rare element extraction is not limited to primary mining. In recent years, significant attention has been directed toward recycling secondary resources. Electronic waste, spent lithium-ion batteries, used industrial catalysts, and degraded permanent magnets all represent rich sources of valuable elements, and their recycling can contribute significantly to sustainable raw material supply.

Laboratory and pilot-scale studies have demonstrated that combining supercritical CO₂ with suitable complexing agents enables the selective separation of elements such as neodymium, dysprosium, cobalt, and nickel with high efficiency. The high selectivity simplifies downstream purification and enhances final product purity.

From an industrial perspective, this technology can serve as a complementary solution alongside existing methods. Particularly for companies active in industrial gases and gas condensates, developing CO₂-based applications can create new value-chain opportunities and elevate their role from simple suppliers to providers of advanced technological solutions.

Comparative Table of Rare Element Extraction Methods

Comparing extraction methods is increasingly important under growing environmental and economic pressures. The table below summarizes key differences between conventional extraction processes and liquid CO₂-based technology:

Chemical Consumption Analysis

In conventional extraction, chemical consumption is one of the primary contributors to cost and pollution. Strong acids are used for dissolution, followed by organic solvents for separation—common but expensive steps. After use, these chemicals become waste streams requiring complex and costly treatment systems.

In contrast, liquid CO₂ extraction relies primarily on physical adjustments of pressure and temperature, minimizing the need for auxiliary chemicals. This reduces both material costs and operational complexity.

Selectivity and Separation Precision

A major challenge in rare element extraction is the chemical similarity among these elements. Conventional methods often result in co-extraction, necessitating additional purification stages. In liquid CO₂ technology, selectivity can be controlled through appropriate complexing agents and precise operational conditions, enabling targeted extraction of specific elements and significantly improving final product purity.

Environmental Impact and Sustainability

Traditional extraction methods typically generate acidic effluents, chemical sludges, and pollutant gases, leading to long-term environmental impacts on soil, water, and ecosystems. In contrast, liquid CO₂ extraction is recognized as a cleaner technology. The CO₂ used can be recycled and reintroduced into the process cycle, minimizing secondary pollution and aligning with stricter environmental regulations.

Safety and Energy Consumption

Handling corrosive and flammable chemicals in conventional processes introduces significant safety risks. CO₂, being non-flammable and non-toxic, enhances overall process safety. Although CO₂ extraction requires high pressure, the elimination of heavy thermal stages and complex purification steps keeps overall energy consumption at acceptable levels.

Environmental and Economic Advantages

Liquid CO₂ extraction significantly reduces dependence on strong acids and toxic solvents, thereby lowering hazardous wastewater generation and treatment needs. CO₂ is often sourced from industrial recovery streams and recycled after use, transforming it from a greenhouse gas liability into a valuable process medium consistent with circular economy principles.

Economically, while high-pressure equipment requires initial capital investment, long-term operational savings—through reduced chemical usage, lower waste treatment costs, and improved extraction efficiency—justify the investment. Higher product purity further enhances added value and market competitiveness.

Technical and Industrial Challenges

Despite its advantages, industrial implementation presents challenges. High-pressure systems require robust design, strict safety standards, and significant infrastructure investment. Developing suitable CO₂-compatible complexing agents with high selectivity demands extensive laboratory and pilot research. Scaling from laboratory to industrial scale also involves uncertainties that must be addressed through detailed techno-economic assessments.

Additionally, advanced technical expertise and skilled personnel are required, which may pose barriers for some companies. However, as industrial experience grows, many of these limitations are expected to diminish.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

Liquid and supercritical carbon dioxide, as green, tunable, and recyclable solvents, offer strong potential to transform the selective extraction of rare elements. This technology can simultaneously reduce environmental impact, improve process efficiency, and enhance economic value. As demand for strategic elements continues to rise, the adoption of innovative and sustainable extraction methods becomes increasingly critical.

For mining and processing industries—and especially for companies active in industrial gases and gas condensates—leveraging advanced CO₂ applications can represent a significant strategic advantage.

————————————————–

resource

1. Watkins, J. J., & McCarthy, T. J.
Polymerization in supercritical carbon dioxide.
Chemical Reviews, 95(6), 2135–2156 (1995).
2. Jessop, P. G., Leitner, W.
Chemical synthesis using supercritical fluids.
Wiley-VCH, Weinheim (1999).
3. Reverchon, E., & De Marco, I.
Supercritical fluid extraction and fractionation of natural matter.
Journal of Supercritical Fluids, 38(2), 146–166 (2006).
4. Binnemans, K., Jones, P. T., Blanpain, B., et al.
Recycling of rare earths: A critical review.
Journal of Cleaner Production, 51, 1–22 (2013).